Mobile apps have clearly become a big business due to billions owning smartphones. One needs to have a foolproof idea in order to come up with an app and make it a big hit in the market. While developing your idea, you have to be unique as well as aware of the current demands of the market. You have to look at the resources, key activities, value proposition, how the whole mobile app development process would work and much more associated things. It is undoubtedly a tough job out of which we expect a good return. Now, if you have an idea but scared of copy cats stealing your concept, you always have an option to get a patent.
To get a patent of your app, you need to know a lot about it like how it is going to work, what all would be the features and in short, all the aspects that explains everything to a stranger about your app.
If you are planning to generate revenue out of your app, that you definitely would, then it is necessary to talk about patents. Patents basically work as a protector of your intellectual property.
Before we move ahead, lets us know what Intellectual property rights are and how the terms patents, copyright and trademarks are closely related yet different.
What is intellectual property?
Intellectual property or IP refers to some kind of invention, literary works, artistic creations such as designing, symbols, name or anything that is a creation of mind and has not been brought to the world earlier.
What are intellectual property rights?
Intellectual property can be protected by law often known as Intellectual property rights through which you can restrict anyone from using or selling similar kind of creation. Moreover, you can earn financial benefits in return of your permission to use or sell it. By striking the correct balance between the interests of innovators and public interest, the IP system strives at fostering an environment which promotes the flourishing of creativity and innovation. There are three major terms coming under IPR.
1. Copyright: Copyright is defined as an exclusive right which is given to the creator of a creative work, may be literary, artistic, musical or of any other form. Copyright laws have been made in order to protect the original expression of an idea. Copyrights granted by the law of a certain state, do not extend beyond the territory of that specific jurisdiction. However, it may vary state to state or country to country. Sometimes, agreements are made with other countries on procedures applicable when works “cross” national borders or national rights are inconsistent. In simpler terms, the basic concept behind providing exclusive rights to the owners is to allow them to secure their work against thefts and also receive economic rewards. There are three basic requirements a work needs to have in order to protect itself by copyright. The creation has to be creative, original as well as fixed, means it should be fixed in a tangible medium of expression.
2. Trademark: Trademark protection also comes under IPR which is a right given to protect names, symbols, devices, designs or words associated with good and services. If we talk in technical terms, “Service mark” is the term used for services whereas trademark is used for both products as well as services. A trademark is given to the owner as an exclusive right through which he/she can protect the usage of a particular symbol or word by some other individual or agency. A trademark is not in place to prevent another individual or company from making or selling the same goods or service under a clearly different mark.
3. Patent: Patent system has been designed in order to encourage inventions that are useful for people and unique in nature. A patent is a right granted to an inventor by the federal government that permits the inventor to exclude others from making, selling or using the invention for a period of time.
Many a time people get confused between copyright, trademark and patent. Though, to get one, you need to be sure what you need to apply for and what means exactly what. Here’s how you can differentiate among three.
Trademarks are generally filed by business or product owners for the protection of names, slogans, words, symbols, image and designing elements that are used to identify that particular firm and distinguish the same from others. If we talk about copyright, it is filed by artists, authors, architects, choreographers and other creative professionals. The tangible form of an idea can be copyrighted but yes, it has to be unique and useful. Patents are generally filed by inventors or designers which protects inventions with an improved or new function. All have their own benefits through which you can differentiate them. Do not get worried if an item comes under multiple categories because it is totally natural and common.
Since, this article is going to be purely about how to take patent for your mobile app, here is the detailed description on what are patents and how the application process works and get a green tick.
What is a Patent?
In legal terms, Patent is defined as the right which is granted to an inventor of product/service/idea from government authority in order to restrict others from making or selling that invention for a period of time.
Patent is a part of the Intellectual property law that also consists of rights like trademark, copyright etc. but those are different forms which should be confused with patent as they have their own different legal definitions.
Before we go ahead, it is important for you to understand that patents can take many forms. Here are the types of patents one can apply for.
1. Utility patent: Utility patent covers creation of new, improved and useful product, process or machine. It is also called patent for invention according to which any other company or individual is not allowed to make, use or sell the invention without authorization from the creator. This is the most common form of patent which most of the people talk about. However, these are really tough to obtain. You have to get involved in a time taking documentation process then it is also expensive to undertake.
2. Provisional patent: A provisional patent works very close to the utility one. Provisional patent involves the formation of a lesser formal documentation which proves that the inventor has complete possession of the invention. The inventor needs to figure out how to make the invention work. Once the process is completed, this form of application goes under Patent Pending section. The work does not end up here. Now, if the inventor fails to submit a formal utility patent within one year, this filing date would be lost. Any public disclosures which is made depending on that provisional patent application will now count on public disclosures to the United States Patent and Trademark Office.
3. Design patent: As the name clearly indicates, a Design patent would protect your designs from being copied by any other individual or business running in the industry. For example, the design of a bottle, shoe, jewelry etc. The document associated with such a kind of patent mostly contains designs related to the invention. Since there are a few words used in a design document, it is pretty much tough to simply search the design patents. A design patent can only be granted if the produce has distinct surface ornamentation or configuration or both. Filing for design patent cost comparatively lower than one for utility patent.
4. Plant patent: A plant patent is an IP right which protects a unique and new plant’s characteristic from being sold, copied or used by others. A patentable plant can be natural, somatic or even bred.
Can apps be patented?
Yes! Because an app is basically a component of interaction methods which is a process that runs on your phone connecting to a remote server that is useful either to store data or process it. However, the code on which the software runs cannot be patented as it already comes under the category of law covered by copyrights.
A mobile app comes in the category of “methods” or “process” which can definitely be patented along with other things like machines, composition of matter, articles etc.
Before proceeding any further, you should first know whether your idea or app is patentable or not. It should not be a clone of Uber you are coming up with. Well, it was just an example! What we are meaning to say here is that a product can only be patented if it does not exist in the market already.
Let us have a look if your app is eligible for the application or not.
Is your app eligible for patent?
Checking the eligibility of your app to get patented is the first and foremost step of getting a patent. You need to perform a patent search to look for similar ideas the market has been bombarded with earlier. Just because an app can be patented does not mean you app is eligible for it. The US Patent and Trademark office suggests doing a thorough patent search before any application. You can search for the related keywords, specially the ones that are related to the core functionalities. Why do you have to do this homework? It’s because even if you get a patent, you can be charged for patent infringement. The patent and trademark office makes an effort to look that your app does not violates any other patent but does not guarantee it.
You have to keep in mind that it is not just an idea that can be patented. You have to provide enough details on how the app is going work as well.
There are certain elements which cannot be patented such as Law of nature, Laws of Physics, mathematical formula and things related to human body.
Your app idea has to be “Novel” which means there should be different from all the earlier inventions. Moreover, there should also be a consequential impact of the difference. Coming up with a difference is not only important to get a patent but also to attract a significant amount of traction. An already exiting idea might not attract audience in a long run even if you try to attract them with offers initially.
Next up, your app has to be “non obvious” which means that someone skilled in your industry line should not consider it as an unexpected development. It is the difficult most criteria to pass as it is a subjective notion. What you might find unique and useful the other person cannot feel so.
Last one, your app has to be “useful” which means you app has to work at least in theory. It is not necessary that it should offer some thing to watch or play but yes, it should at least something to the user. Rather than just claiming the ownership, you should know and clearly explain how this app is going to work. What are the features it is going to offer, where is it useful, is it even needed are some of the questions that will take you to conclusion of whether your app would qualify the “being useful” criteria or not?
How to apply for Patent?
File a provisional patent application
By now, you must be aware of the terminologies related to the patent applications. What would you like to go for- a provisional application or non-provisional one? Let me get straight to the point. Most of the developers first go for a provisional patent application as it lets them secure a filing date till then they can prepare stuff. Still, one needs to provide much details like flow charts, drawings, content and other visuals that can be clarified later. But yes, it eliminates much of your efforts. Moreover, you will get an idea of how things work so that you get nervous or stressed out later while working on more complex things.
When a provisional application gets a green tick, your application goes into pending status which gives you a timeline of 1 year in which you can easily collect resources for the app completion. Moreover, you will get enough time to see if your app idea is even going to work or not. When you secure a filing date, you will be on a safer side as it helps authorities determine who was first to file.
There are some charges you need to transact in order to apply which can carry vary nation wise significantly.
Since, your app goes into pending status after applying for the provisional patent. You should be ready with all the stuff required to get a real and final patent before the filing date. Failing to do so, your application gets cancelled simply or you might have to face other circumstances.
File a regular patent:
After filing a provisional patent, you need to go for a regular one within a year. If you do not do so, you will simply lose your filing date. The real and detailed examination is carried out once you file for a regular patent.
Your patent application would be broken into four parts- Specification, Claims, Abstract and Drawings.
If you are in an assumption that it’s a day or a month’s process, then let me tell you it might even take your application a time period of 2-3 years to get a green tick from the authorities. The examiner would not straight away approve it, it will need a lot of refining as the time passes. You might have to carry out a lot of revisions.
If you are looking forward to seeing some examples, then we would like to tell you that Google has an altogether different search engine for patents. If you go to patents.google.com and perform a search, you will get to see a lot of documents which can give enough idea about how it works.
Let us go into detailing.
1. Specification: Specification would be a collection of information on what makes your application different from all the other existing concepts in the market. It should be so clear that even a novice can understand how to create the app from scratch and what are the important aspects without seeking your help. You also need to disclose the best mode of creating this application.
The specification would be consisting of title, background, summary and description. The title needs to be short and clear enough to understand the idea of your app. The background information has to be elaborated in terms of context of the invention. It should include all relevant theory along with a clear explanation on how your app is differentiated from all other prior inventions.
In the summary part, you have to provide a brief description on how the app is going to work and solve the existing problems in the market. Basically, you need to summarize the whole idea so well that the examiner can get a lot of things looking at just the summary. Then comes Description which has be descriptive obviously. You need to provide a thorough explanation of your app in this section and it has to be so clear and to the point that even that anybody halfway competent in the field would be able to replicate your app.
2. Claims: It is the most important part of your application in which you clearly state for which all parts of the application, you need ownership. You might not be eligible to take patent for the whole app as there must be some section which are already present in some one else’s patent. You need to define the features which are unique and only generated for the first time so that they can be counted under inventions since patents are all about inventions.
3. Drawings: If there is a visual representation that your patent uses, then you will definitely have to include the visual representations and related figures in the document. If you are confused about what to include then you can go through some samples, may be some already approved patent in your industry and see where you idea stands or what are the things you can include in this particular section.
4. Filing: There are two options to file the application. You can either mail it or file it electronically. If you are sure that the application is so refined that it can get approved in one go then, filing electronically can be easy for you but since that is slight impossible, you can file by mail. Make sure to keep the copies of your application. Include the title and application filing date with your mail. You can use self-addressed postcard in order to receive your receipt.
Mobile app companies have a period of 12 months to file a provisional patent application after they have introduced their product to the market. Then, they have additional 12 months to file a full patent else the filing date gets lost. In the US, according to the agency’s rule “provisional application automatically becomes abandoned when its pendency period expires 12 months after the provisional application filing date”.
Either you can yourself create the document or you can also take help from consultants out there who will add a pace to the work. In all, patents are taken to protect your app from being copied still many would be there who will add a fresh twist to the application and might release it along with your app. Here is a quick advice! Bear in mind to carry out rigorous marketing after you come up with that unique idea. People would not automatically come to you. You need to make efforts in order to visible.
Still, protecting an Intellectual property is a complicated and time taking process which evolves at every level during its lifecycle. Whether we talk about research, innovation or development itself, the evolution does not encounter any halt.